The Guardian March 14, 2001

Recession: capitalism does not work

The figures of the economists and politicians are now revealing what 
millions of workers and farmers have known for a long time  Australia's 
economy is in recession.

Approximately every ten years the economy takes a downturn.

Living standards go down, the government talks about belt-tightening, 
services and welfare payments are cut.

Workers are thrown out of their jobs, and employers proclaim that they 
cannot afford any wage increases, effectively cutting wages by intimidating 
remaining employees to work overtime without any payment.

Companies go into receivership, thieving the workers' entitlements.

It is a crisis of overproduction that are inevitable in a capitalist 
society. Workers produce too many commodities that cannot be sold.

Shops bulge with products but workers do not have the money to buy them. 
Investment stops as unsold goods pile up.

This is the madness and criminality of the capitalist system.

A main factor that has reduced the ability of workers to buy is the GST. It 
has forced prices up considerably, and the tax cuts did not compensate.

The example of the housing industry makes the point. Homebuilding has 
slumped, even though new houses are needed.

It is because the GST has pushed up the price of building houses and 
potential buyers have given up.

The prices of many other commodities have also risen. The GST is not 
imposed on fruit and vegetables but prices have risen substantially. The 
price of bread has gone up by at least 10 per cent.

The periodical crises of overproduction are a direct result of the 
exploitation of the working people.

Only a fraction of the values that workers create are passed on to them in 
the form of wages. The rest goes as profits to shareholders and the 
purchase of new equipment intended to reduce the number of workers employed 
still more and further increase profits.

Telstra is an example  it has just declared a record profit of $2.6 
billion for the half year to December 2000.

When delivering the Telstra report last year, Managing Director, Dr 
Switkowski gave emphasis to his plans to sack 10,000 workers. This year he 
confirmed that Telstra was on target in reducing its head count.

At the same time, millions of dollars will be paid out to shareholders who 
do no work in Telstra whatever. They produce nothing and provide no 

Overall, the economy is unplanned. No manufacturer knows what will be 
needed in one year's time. But, when too much has been produced they sack 

This boom and bust cycle has continued during the whole existence of 

Just so long as there is private ownership of the means of production and 
of the commodities produced while, on the other hand, the masses of workers 
own little or nothing, the cycle will continue.

From recession to depression?

This time, the recession could slide into a full-scale depression. The 
economies of the major capitalist countries are all running into severe 

The economy of Japan is described as nearing "collapse". In an attempt to 
get the Japanese economy going again, interest rates have been reduced to 
only 0.15 per cent and the Japanese government has dished out huge tax 

But these measures are not working because they don't affect the real 
reasons for the problems facing the Japanese economy.

The American economy is slowing considerably, as are the economies of the 
industrialised European countries.

The prices of commodities such as iron ore, coal, natural gas, tin, gold 
and other resources are low, and these are among Australia's main trading 

Despite the attempts of Howard and Costello to "talk up" the economy, the 
reality is to be seen in the slump in the exchange rate of the Australian 

Few wish to buy it, and this would not be the case if the economy were 

The slump in the dollar exchange rate may bring some benefits to those 
capitalists who have commodities to export, but it makes the cost of 
imports into Australia that much dearer.

The cost of importing cars, aeroplanes and computers, very few of which are 
manufactured here, continually blow out our trade deficit.

Another commodity affected is oil. Even though Australia is self-sufficient 
in oil production, the price of oil is determined by the US dollar price 
and not by local production costs. The price will increase as the exchange 
rate of the Australian dollar falls. Furthermore, Australia's oil resources 
are largely owned by overseas transnational companies.

The politicians and economists are not telling the truth about the economy.

Costello claims that there is only a slump in the building industry.

Howard has blamed the deepening crisis on the fact that the Reserve Bank 
put interest rates up too high last year.

Well-known economist Ross Gittins (SMH 8/3/01) tells us that one 
reason is that people were saving rather than spending last July's income 
tax cut. He says that people should start spending their tax cuts as soon 
as they like!

He also suggests that it is all in the mind saying that the more the nation 
focuses on the question [of recession], the more likely it is to come 

All these explanations are merely excuses that deal with the results, not 
the causes. They are aimed to obscure the real reasons and hide them from 
the people.

It is the private enterprise system itself that is the real cause  the 
exploitation of all who work.

The sackings, long hours and inadequate wages, working overtime for no pay, 
thieving the entitlements, cutbacks on safety, and the introduction of new 
technology are all examples of how exploitation occurs.

They all have the deliberate purpose of reducing the number of workers 

Another cause is the planlessness of the capitalist system. The aim is to 
produce commodities and to sell them at a profit  the maximum profit.

But as long as no single producer knows the market, and whether what is 
produced will be sold, the individual capitalist is a blind player.

They are playing with the lives and jobs of the workers, who are thrown out 
of employment just as soon as they can be no longer exploited at a profit. 

The only way out of this vicious system is the socialist alternative  the 
far-reaching extension of public ownership of the means of production, the 
introduction of economic planning, a completely restructured tax system.

We must throw out of government those political parties that cling to a 
system that brings so much misery, injustice, insecurity and hopelessness.

Join us in helping to bring this rotten and rotting system to an end.

Back to index page