The Guardian November 8, 2000

Licence to spill

The Maritime Union of Australia (MUA) is calling for a parliamentary 
inquiry into the grounding last week of a Malaysian container ship, the 
Bunga Teratai Satu, on the Great Barrier Reef. The union said its 
concerns over deregulation of Australia's shipping industry have been borne 
out by the accident. The vessel was laden with toxic chemicals and 1,200 
tonnes of fuel.

The Bunga, which held a permit to carry domestic cargo, has been 
subjected to five port inspections, the last in Sydney's Port Botany in 
August this year, when it was detained.

"This outrageous threat to our World Heritage Barrier Reef is a direct 
result of the Coalition Government policy of allowing foreign flag ships to 
take over our domestic trade", said MUA Deputy National Secretary, Paddy 

"The Bunga Teratai Satu is just one of the new recruits to the 
Federal Government's shonky fleet", he said.

"They've got these poorly regulated vessels with badly trained crew 
undercutting Australian ships in what are effectively tax avoidance schemes 
getting direct sponsorship from Transport Minister John Anderson and his 
Canberra mates."

Cabotage laws restrict Australia's domestic trade to Australian flag 
shipping except where no suitable Australian ship is available.

Shippers and freight forwarders, lured by rates afforded by foreign ships 
employing third world crew  mostly poorly trained and low paid  find 
loopholes in the Act to avoid using the national flag vessels.

The Australian Maritime Safety Authority (AMSA) does spot checks on ships, 
but inspectors are not always able to ensure all ships are seaworthy from 
the inspections, which take place only a few hours before the vessels sail.

In recent years the AMSA has seen a winding back of its funding under 
current Federal Government policies. Also, a number of senior management 
people have left, disillusioned by government intervention.

The Bunga was last inspected by the AMSA in Port Botany on August 8 
this year. The inspector noted that ships officers were not able to 
demonstrate operation of radio equipment, that engine room ventilation fire 
dampers were defective and the means of lifeboat recovery inoperative.

The scrutiny the vessel has been put under in recent years demonstrates the 
AMSA's serious concerns and yet, on August 3, just five days before the 
ship was detained, and after numerous inspections which detected defects, 
John Anderson awarded a licence for the ship to carry Australian domestic 
cargo for 12 months.

The MUA is calling for a parliamentary inquiry into the circumstances of 
the awarding of the licence.

"It's almost as if the Government gave this ship the licence to pollute and 
endanger our waterways because of their determination to destroy Australian 
shipping", said Paddy Crumlin.

"Our ships can't compete with these vessels because we maintain safety and 
training standards second to none in the world. We hold John Anderson 
responsible for any damage coming out of this."

Mr Crumlin pointed out that only two months ago the Minister was smugly 
boasting about his victory in the Federal Court against MUA efforts to 
prohibit the use of these types of vessels in the Australian domestic 
shipping industry.

Shipping paper Lloyds List/Daily Commercial News reports that AMSA 
has subjected the Bunga Teratai Satu to five inspections in the past 
two years, detaining the vessel once.

When it ploughed into the reef off the coast of Queensland, it was six 
miles off course and had a permit to carry Australian cargo between Sydney, 
Bell Bay (Tasmania) or Burnie (Tasmania) and Fremantle (Western Australia).

Back to index page