The Guardian October 25,2000

Britain: Give us back our public rail service!

by Daphne Liddle

Just three weeks ago, the survivors of the Paddington rail crash said, on 
the anniversary of that disaster, that nothing had been done to prevent it 
happening again at any time  and it just has.

The 12.IOpm inter-city from London Kings Cross to Leeds on Tuesday last 
week derailed just outside Hatfield and came to grief with four dead and 29 

Initial theories on the cause of the accident included terrorism, vandalism 
and faulty train wheels. But as we go to press it seems most likely that a 
broken rail found at the site of the accident was the cause.

A disturbing picture is emerging. The transport union RMT has reported that 
subcontractor Balfour Beatty has been working in the area for Railtrack 
replacing old and damaged rails. Some were replaced last May, the rest, 
including the one that broke, due to be done next month.

The union also reports an increase in the numbers of cracks in rails on 
that line since it has been used regularly by Eurostar trains, with much 
heavier than usual engines.

The accident happened on a bend, as the GNER train was travelling at 185 
miles an hour.

RMT is asking that if Balfour Beatty knew there were problems with cracked 
rails in that stretch, why a warning was not passed on to the train 
companies to restrict speed, especially on bends where centrifugal forces 
put extra strain on wheels and rails.

Since the crash, Railtrack has imposed speed restrictions on all similar 
stretches of track throughout Britain.

This has led to a total disruption of rail services and exposes the 
privatised rail services' inability to deliver a safe and efficient rail 
service as they are contracted to do.

Rail safety expert Roy Bell said the root cause of the accident was the way 
that British Rail was divided up when it was privatised by the Tories in 

With so much fragmentation into Railtrack, train operators, subcontractors 
like Balfour Beatty and so on, there is no single body to hold responsible, 
no single chain of command.

All the companies involved can blame each other and pass the buck.

Last December, the Health and Safety Executive fined Railtrack over a 20 
percent rise in the number of broken rails discovered annually since 
privatisation. There have been umpteen reports criticising railtrack for 
poor maintenance.

Rail workers have many times pointed out that the subcontractors employed 
by Railtrack to do the work  as cheaply as possible to protect profits  
employ low-paid, unskilled workers who do not have the experience and 
safety culture of the old British Rail track workers.

There have been enough long, drawn out, fruitless inquiries to know that 
what is needed is a big increase in spending on safety on the railways.

But the privatised companies are not going to deliver this as long as 
profit is their main motive. Railtrack makes more than Ll million in profit 
every day and the train companies are doing nicely too.

The only way to control the way the railways are run and to restore a 
culture of safety is to bring them back into public ownership.

* * *
New Worker, paper of New Communist Party of Britain, abridged

Back to index page